Before You Replace the CEO: The Smarter Intervention for PE-Backed Businesses
The Hidden Cost of CEO Turnover
Across private equity portfolios, nearly half of portfolio CEOs are replaced before exit. It’s rarely in the plan. A process intended to unlock value often does the opposite. Months are lost in search, onboarding, and recovery. Momentum fades, remaining management becomes restless, and leadership credibility takes time to rebuild.
In many cases, replacement is a reaction to pressure rather than a planned transition. It feels decisive, but the reality is usually slower recovery, higher cost, and a period of drift just when the business needs focus most. Before making that call, it’s worth asking a simple question: has the CEO been given the structure and support required to succeed?
When Performance Starts to Slide
You can usually see it coming. Forecasts get revised, board packs start to carry caveats, and the atmosphere around meetings becomes tense. The CEO looks increasingly isolated. Conversations move from “how do we help?” to “who do we know?”.
Replacing a CEO often feels like the cleanest fix, but it rarely delivers quick results. It disrupts relationships, unsettles teams, and risks losing valuable operational knowledge. What’s often needed isn’t a new leader, but a reset.
The Overlooked Option
In many cases, a short, structured intervention with an experienced Strategic CEO Advisor achieves more, faster, and with far less disruption than a leadership change. It brings discipline, focus, and a recovery plan the team can act on immediately.
This isn’t about motivational coaching or soft development work. It’s about providing the CEO with a trusted and practical partner who can help them think clearly, rebalance priorities, and lead effectively under pressure. Someone who understands the private equity environment, the demands of value-creation plans, and the operational reality of running a business with finite bandwidth.
What It Delivers
A Strategic CEO Advisor can quickly help to:
-
Reconnect the CEO and board around a shared value-creation plan
-
Define 90-day priorities that create visible traction
-
Introduce a structured recovery plan to stabilise performance and rebuild confidence
-
Provide the guidance and support needed to make that plan happen inside the business
-
Strengthen alignment between investors, management, and key teams
-
Identify where structure, bandwidth, or leadership rhythm are missing
-
Tackle performance barriers without causing organisational shock
The result is often a team that steadies itself, a CEO who regains authority, and a board that sees progress without upheaval.
The Economics of Support
Replacing a CEO typically costs many times more than a targeted advisory intervention. Beyond the search and transition fees, there’s the silent cost of lost time, missed opportunities, and broken continuity. Institutional knowledge walks out of the door, and it takes months for a new leader to rebuild trust and understanding.
By contrast, an experienced advisor can be in place within weeks, working alongside the CEO to guide implementation, protect value, and restore direction. The focus is immediate and measurable: stabilise the business, rebuild confidence, and regain momentum.
Why It Works in PE Settings
Portfolio company leadership is a unique environment. CEOs operate under close investor scrutiny, with compressed timelines and heightened accountability. They are often excellent operators who have never been tested in this specific context.
Having a trusted advisor who understands the dynamics between funders, management, and operational delivery can make the difference between a leader under strain and a leader performing at their best. In short, it’s not about replacing the CEO; it’s about giving them the tools and clarity to deliver what the investment demands.
A Better First Step
None of this suggests that CEO replacement is never necessary. Sometimes it is. But too often, replacement is used as the first response rather than the last.
The smarter approach is to intervene early, while confidence in the CEO still exists but support is clearly needed. Once that confidence is gone, it is almost never regained. Acting before the situation reaches that point gives the best chance of recovery, preserves value, and demonstrates clear stewardship from the board.
If performance stabilises, the business keeps its knowledge, culture, and continuity. If it doesn’t, the decision to replace becomes clearer and cleaner, with evidence that every practical step was taken first.
From Recovery to Renewal
For CEOs and MDs already under pressure, there is a structured route back to control.
The 10 Steps to Business Recovery and the CEO/MD Guide to Leading the 10 Steps outline the exact process I use with leadership teams to regain focus, stabilise operations, and rebuild momentum.
It’s often the simplest way to determine whether the business truly needs new leadership or just the right support at the right time.
The Takeaway
Replacing a CEO should never be an act of frustration. It should be a measured, informed decision made after every alternative has been explored.
Before starting another search, it’s worth considering a short-term Strategic CEO Advisor engagement. It preserves value, maintains stability, and often delivers results faster than a replacement ever could.
If you’re hearing signs that management are firefighting or sense that leadership energy is fading, the moment to act is now. Not after confidence has gone, but while it still exists and can be channelled into recovery. The answer may not be a new CEO; it may be structured support to help the current one succeed.
